Get tales like this delivered straight to your inbox. Join The 74 Publication
Sixteen-year-old Andie Murphy isn’t on TikTok. She turned off monitoring on YouTube and deleted Instagram months in the past over its synthetic intelligence coverage and issues about posts getting used to prepare AI.
As a lot as doable, the highschool junior has tried to arrange guardrails on rapid-fire social feeds to restrict scrolling and the attract of algorithms’ strategies. “For my very own self management,” she stated.
Murphy could also be an outlier amongst her friends, however more and more many teenagers share her emotions of data overload and consciousness that they will’t belief all the pieces they learn on social media. “There’s simply a lot unhealthy data on the market that it typically will get jumbled up,” Murphy stated. “It’s simply onerous to discern what somebody’s intent is with one thing.”
As members of Gen Z — born between 1997 and 2012 — highschool college students like Murphy have grown up with smartphones and social media. It’s a digital world the place algorithms gasoline countless scrolling and conspiracy theories really feel just like the norm.
That’s significantly true for Murphy and her classmates at Owasso Excessive Faculty in Owasso, Oklahoma, a shortly rising Tulsa suburb of 39,000. It’s a spot that final 12 months felt the extraordinary glare of going viral and the chaotic circulate of reports, half-truths and hate following the loss of life of Nex Benedict, a 16-year-old nonbinary scholar who died a day after an altercation within the women’ lavatory.
As a information literacy skilled working to help educators, I just lately spoke with 12 college students at Owasso Excessive Faculty about their information habits and what it’s like looking for credible data in an internet surroundings that continually exams their means to know what’s true.
Listed here are 4 takeaways from our conversations.
1. Teenagers are drawn to conspiracy theories — and should not understand they will lead down harmful rabbit holes.
A fall 2024 examine by the Information Literacy Mission discovered that eight in 10 teenagers on social media say they encounter conspiracy theories, with 81% of these teenagers reporting that they’re inclined to imagine a minimum of one in all them.
Senior Elijah Wagner, 18, advised me he typically turns to X, previously Twitter, and types by means of “the chaos” of content material on the platform to maintain up with information.
“There’s numerous conspiracy theories on Twitter,” Wagner stated, including that a lot of what he sees are “individuals who simply wish to make a giant deal about one thing.”
For some younger folks, a part of the enchantment is that these narratives really feel enjoyable and entertaining. College students I spoke with rattled off viral rumors they’ve seen about celebrities like Beyoncé. However as with the kids in our nationwide survey, Owasso college students additionally reported seeing conspiracies that went nicely past celeb gossip, together with disproven theories concerning the Earth being flat and falsehoods about 9/11.
Although publicity isn’t the identical as perception, seeing a declare repeated sufficient — even one which begins out as a joke — could make it really feel true. “It will get to the purpose the place it’s form of onerous to not imagine a few of them,” stated Kelsey Perry, 18.
2. Friends can play an essential position in fact-checking.
In on-line areas, fact-checking is one thing many college students attempt to do. Amongst teenagers who have interaction with news-related social media posts, almost eight in 10 report that they a minimum of typically fact-check these posts earlier than sharing or liking them, in keeping with our examine. Those that have been taught media literacy have been extra prone to say they ceaselessly test for accuracy earlier than posting on-line.
Analysis has instructed that we’re extra prone to imagine fact-checks from folks we all know.
On the winter day of my go to, the Los Angeles wildfires dominated on-line dialog. Information of the fires had reached college students not solely by means of the mighty curation of their TikTok For You pages, but in addition by means of household and buddies.
One scholar admitted she hadn’t saved up with the fires as a result of they appear far faraway from their Oklahoma group. She added that the fires, in any case, have been taking place all the way in which “in Atlanta.”
“No, it’s in L.A.,” an 18-year-old classmate stated, chiming in with a fact-check.
The group laughed, agreed and moved on to explain movies they’d seen of the destruction.
Throughout their lunch hour within the library, these college students continued biking by means of a technique of shared meaning-making: providing data, testing it towards one another’s data and deciphering it as a gaggle.
When conspiracy theories got here up, a junior talked about seeing posts suggesting the Holocaust didn’t occur. “However I’m fairly certain that did occur,” she added, “as a result of isn’t there, like, museums for it and stuff?”
One other scholar confirmed, saying they simply discovered concerning the Holocaust in historical past class the day earlier than. A win for real-time social correction — and a reminder of why it’s essential for college kids to really feel comfy entering into the position of fact-checker to share what they know with friends.
3. Sure, teenagers flip to influencers, however standards-based information nonetheless has a spot.
We all know many younger folks see social media influencers as trusted sources, even over information retailers. In truth, our survey discovered that eight in 10 teenagers say that the knowledge information organizations produce is both extra biased than or about the identical as different content material creators on-line.
In every of my conversations, it didn’t take lengthy for speak of social media to broach the story that final 12 months turned this highschool right into a nationwide fixture of grief and viral debate. Reflecting on the loss of life of their classmate and the crush of nationwide consideration that ensued, college students recalled when misinformation turned private and painful.
Hateful feedback flooded school-associated social media accounts. Classmates stayed house following a wave of threats towards the college. College students described seeing a protest unfold exterior classroom home windows whereas following alongside on a TikTok livestream. One scholar remembered consuming lunch with a instructor moderately than within the cafeteria as a result of a pal felt scared.
In addition they watched celebrities and influencers weigh in.
For Murphy, who tries to restrict her social media use, final 12 months marked a turning level. She stated an influencer she adopted for political commentary on present occasions posted concerning the Owasso scholar’s loss of life earlier than many particulars had been confirmed. “Seeing them make that submit actually made me see that perhaps they weren’t as credible as I initially thought they have been,” Murphy stated.
Now Murphy stated she tries to test a number of credible sources for information to check what she’s listening to.
Different college students advised me one thing comparable: Although many individuals their age comply with influencers, information retailers nonetheless have a spot, particularly for tales that meet a sure threshold of significance. (“If it’s sufficiently big,” or “if I’m scared concerning the information,” one 16-year-old stated.)
4. They need information literacy instruction.
The Information Literacy Mission’s examine reveals that an amazing majority of teenagers (94%) need media literacy instruction, however most aren’t getting it.
I heard a lot the identical at Owasso Excessive Faculty. Some college students stated they’d heard phrases like “lateral studying” at school: if you depart a supply of data and do a fast search to be taught extra concerning the declare or supply. However in addition they advised me they wished media literacy might be woven all through their courses, from statistics to science.
Library media specialist Melinda Gallagher has been instructing information literacy classes for about eight years in her position at Owasso. “I really feel like that is a method we might help our college students — and assist ourselves, to be frank — with determining what’s actual and what’s not,” Gallagher stated. “It’s essential for our future as a rustic.”
College students didn’t ask for this on-line quagmire or create it. But it surely’s a world they’re anticipated to navigate. “Social media is so prevalent … it’s not going away,” stated Makenzy Holm, 17. “We’d as nicely be taught to make use of it to our greatest means.”
Get tales like these delivered straight to your inbox. Join The 74 Publication