Get tales like this delivered straight to your inbox. Join The 74 Publication
Texas public college directors, dad and mom and schooling specialists fear {that a} new legislation to switch the state’s standardized check may probably improve pupil stress and the period of time they spend taking exams, as a substitute of decreasing it.
The brand new legislation comes amid criticism that the State of Texas Evaluation of Educational Readiness, or STAAR, creates an excessive amount of stress for college kids and devotes an excessive amount of educational time to the check. The up to date system goals to ease the stress of a single examination by changing STAAR with three shorter exams, which can be administered initially, center and finish of the yr. It’ll additionally ban follow exams, which Texas Schooling Company Commissioner Mike Morath has mentioned can take up weeks of instruction time and aren’t confirmed to assist college students do higher on the standardized check. However some dad and mom and academics fear the modifications gained’t go far sufficient and that three exams will triple the stress.
The legislation additionally requires the TEA to review tips on how to cut back the load testing carries on the state’s annual college accountability scores — which STAAR critics say is one motive why the check is so annoying and absorbs a lot studying time — and create a approach for the outcomes of the three new exams to be factored into the scores.
That report is just not due till the 2029-30 college yr, and the TEA is just not required to implement these findings. Some fear the brand new legislation will imply colleges’ scores will proceed to closely depend upon the outcomes from the end-of-year check, whereas requiring college students to begin taking three exams. In different phrases: identical stress, extra testing.
Cementing ‘what college districts are already doing’
The Texas Legislature handed Home Invoice 8 in the course of the second extra time lawmaking session this yr to scrap the STAAR check.
Lots of the reforms are supposed to higher monitor college students’ tutorial progress all through the college yr.
For the early and mid-year exams, colleges will have the ability to select from a menu of nationally acknowledged assessments permitted by the TEA. The company will create the third check. Beneath the legislation, the three new exams will use percentile ranks evaluating college students to their friends in Texas; the third may also assess a pupil’s grasp of the curriculum.
As well as, scores can be required to be launched about two days after college students take the examination, so academics can higher tailor their classes to pupil wants.
State Sen. Paul Bettencourt, R-Houston, one of many architects behind the push to revamp the state’s standardized check, mentioned he would love the primary two exams to “develop into a part of studying” to allow them to assist college students put together for the end-of-year examination.
However regardless of the modifications, the brand new testing system will possible resemble the present one when it launches within the 2027-28 college yr, schooling coverage specialists say.
“It’s gonna take a few years earlier than dad and mom notice, to be trustworthy, that you understand, did they really remove STAAR?” mentioned Bob Popinski with Increase Your Hand Texas, an schooling advocacy nonprofit.
Since many colleges already conduct a number of exams all year long, the legislation will “mainly codify what college districts are already doing,” Popinski mentioned.
Lawmakers instructed TEA to develop a method to measure pupil progress based mostly on the outcomes from the three exams. However that metric gained’t be prepared when the brand new testing system launches within the 2027-28 college yr. Meaning outcomes from the standardized exams, and their weight within the state’s college accountability scores system, will stay much like what they’re now.
Each Texas college district and campus presently receives an A-F ranking based mostly on commencement benchmarks and the way college students carry out on state exams, their enchancment in these areas, and the way effectively they educate deprived college students. The most effective rating out of the primary two classes accounts for many of their total ranking. The remainder relies on their rating within the final class.
The accountability scores are excessive stakes for varsity districts, which may face state sanctions for failing grades — from being compelled to shut college campuses to the ousting of their democratically elected college boards.
Supporters of the state’s accountability system say it is important to evaluate whether or not colleges are doing a very good job at educating Texas youngsters.
“The final check is a part of the accountability ranking, and that’s not going to vary,” Bettencourt mentioned.
Critics say the present scores system fails to take note of a whole lot of the work colleges are doing to assist youngsters succeed exterior of getting ready them for standardized exams.
“Our college districts are doing a whole lot of attention-grabbing, nice issues on the market for our children,” Popinski mentioned. “Teachers and extracurricular actions and co-curricular actions, and people simply aren’t being included into the accountability report in any respect.”
In response to calls to judge pupil success past testing, HB 8 additionally instructs the TEA to trace pupil participation in pre-Ok, extracurriculars and workforce coaching in center colleges. However none of these metrics can be factored into colleges’ scores.
“There may be another curiosity in taking a look at different components for accountability scores, but it surely’s not mandated. It’s simply going to be reviewed and surveyed,” Bettencourt mentioned.
Scholar stress worries
Although many colleges already conduct testing all year long, Popinski mentioned the brand new system created by HB 8 may probably increase test-related stress amongst college students.
State Rep. Brad Buckley, R-Salado, who sponsored the testing overhaul within the Texas Home, wrote in a press release that “TEA will decide testing protocols by their regular course of.” This implies it will likely be as much as TEA to determine whether or not to maintain or change the principles that it presently makes use of for the STAAR check. These embody that colleges dedicate three to 4 hours to the examination and that directors create seating charts, unfold out desks and handle restroom breaks.
Faculty directors mentioned the worst-case state of affairs could be if all three of the brand new exams needed to observe lockdown protocols like those that presently include STAAR. Holly Ferguson, superintendent of Prosper ISD, mentioned the high-pressure atmosphere related to the state’s standardized check makes a few of her college students in poor health.
“It shouldn’t be that we now have children sick and anxiousness goes by the roof as a result of they know the following check is coming,” Ferguson mentioned.
The TEA didn’t reply to a request for remark.
HB 8 additionally seeks to restrict the time academics spend getting ready college students for state assessments, partly by banning benchmark exams for 3-8 grades. Bettencourt informed the Tribune the brand new system is predicted to avoid wasting 22.5 educational hours per pupil.
Buckley mentioned the brand new legislation “will cut back the general variety of exams a pupil takes in addition to the time they spend on state assessments all through the college yr, dramatically relieving the stress and stress attributable to over-testing.”
However some critics fear that any time saved by banning follow exams can be misplaced by testing 3 times a yr. In 2022, Florida modified its testing system from a single examination to 3 exams initially, center and finish of the yr. Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis mentioned the brand new system would cut back check time by 75%, however the variety of minutes college students spent taking exams virtually doubled the yr the brand new system went into impact.
Popinski added that a lot of the stress the check induces comes from the heavy weight the end-of-year evaluation holds on a faculty’s accountability ranking. The stress to carry out that the present system locations on college district directors transfers to academics and college students, critics have mentioned.
“The pressures are going to be virtually precisely the identical,” Popinski mentioned.
What dad and mom, educators need for the brand new check
Retired Fort Price instructor Jim Ekrut mentioned he worries in regards to the ban on follow exams, as a result of in his expertise, check preparations helped cut back his college students’ anxiousness.
Ekrut mentioned academics’ expertise assessing college students is one motive why educators ought to be concerned in creating the brand new end-of-year examination.
“The higher selections are going to be made with enter from folks proper on that firing line,” Ekrut mentioned.
HB 8 requires {that a} committee of educators appointed by the commissioner opinions the brand new check that TEA will create. Some, like Ferguson and David Vinson, former superintendent of Wylie ISD who began at Conroe this week, mentioned they hope the menu of potential assessments districts can choose for the primary two exams features a nationwide program they already use referred to as Measures of Educational Progress, or MAP.
The Prosper and Wylie districts are some that administer MAP exams initially, center and finish of the yr. Greater than 4,500 college districts nationwide use these on-line exams, which change the problem of the questions as college students log their solutions to higher assess their talent degree and progress. A 2024 examine performed by the group that runs MAP discovered that the check is a robust indicator of how college students carry out on the end-of-year standardized check.
Standards-based exams like STAAR measure a pupil’s grasp on grade-level abilities, whereas norm-based exams like MAP measure a pupil’s progress over the course of instruction. Vinson described this program as a “checkup,” whereas STAAR is an “post-mortem.”
Rachel Spires, whose youngsters take MAP exams at Sunnyvale ISD, mentioned MAP testing doesn’t put as a lot stress on college students as STAAR does.
Spires mentioned her youngsters’s schedules are rearranged for the month of April, when Sunnyvale administers the STAAR check, and oldsters are barred from coming to campus for lunch. MAP exams, alternatively, usually take much less time to finish, and the college has fewer guidelines for the way they’re administered.
“When the MAP exams come round, they don’t do the modified schedules, and so they don’t do the assessment packets and prep testing or something like that,” Spires mentioned. “It’s identical to, ‘Okay, tomorrow you’re gonna do a MAP check,’ and it’s over in like an hour.”
For Ferguson, the Prosper ISD superintendent, a relaxed atmosphere round testing is vital to reaching the brand new legislation’s purpose of decreasing pupil stress.
“If it’s simply one other day in school, I’m all in,” Ferguson mentioned. “But when we lock it down, and we create a really compliance-driven system that’s very archaic and anxiety- and worry-inducing to the purpose that it begins having potential dangerous results on our children … our academics and our dad and mom, I’m not okay with that.”
This text initially appeared in The Texas Tribune at https://www.texastribune.org/2025/09/24/texas-staar-replacement-map-testing/. The Texas Tribune is a member-supported, nonpartisan newsroom informing and interesting Texans on state politics and coverage. Be taught extra at texastribune.org.
Get tales like these delivered straight to your inbox. Join The 74 Publication